Severance agreement: 7 things to check before you sign
A severance offer often arrives in the same meeting as the bad news, with a signature line and a deadline. It's tempting to sign just to make the day end. Try not to. A severance agreement is a contract, and you only get to read it once before you're bound by it. Here are seven things to check. This is general information, not legal advice, and the details vary by state and situation.
First, a point that surprises people: no federal law requires severance. The Department of Labor says it's a matter of agreement between you and your employer (DOL). The WARN Act can require 60 days' notice for large layoffs, but it's about notice, not pay. So if you're offered severance, it's usually in exchange for something. Find out what.
1. What you're giving up
Almost every severance agreement includes a release, where you agree not to sue the company over anything that happened up to the day you sign. That can include discrimination, harassment or unpaid wages. There are limits. A release can't cover claims that arise after you sign, and an agreement can't stop you from filing a charge with the EEOC or taking part in its investigation. The EEOC calls a clause that tries to do so invalid and unenforceable (EEOC Q&A). If you think you were treated unfairly, this is the section to bring to a lawyer.
2. How long you have
If you're 40 or older and the agreement waives age discrimination claims, federal law requires at least 21 days to think it over, or 45 days if it's part of a group layoff, plus 7 days after signing to change your mind. A material change to the final offer restarts the 21 days. For group layoffs the company also has to give you a written list of the job titles and ages of everyone selected and not selected (29 CFR 1625.22).
At any age, ask for time in writing if you need it. You can sign sooner if you've decided you want to, but it has to be your choice, not something you were pushed into.
3. What you're paid, and when
Look at the amount, but also how it's paid. A lump sum and weekly installments are different things, especially if installments stop when you start a new job or break a rule in the agreement. Also check whether the package includes things you might already be owed, like accrued vacation. The Labor Department notes that federal law doesn't require vacation pay, and it's a matter of agreement or state law (DOL), so ask your employer in writing how yours is handled.
4. How it's taxed
Severance counts as taxable wages. If it's paid separately from your regular pay, your employer can withhold a flat 22% in some cases, and Social Security and Medicare taxes apply either way (IRS Publication 15). A flat rate may not match what you'll actually owe, so the IRS says to make sure enough is withheld (IRS). Set some of it aside.
5. Your health insurance
Severance doesn't automatically keep your health plan going, so ask the plan administrator when your coverage ends. You'll have at least 60 days to choose COBRA, and employers can offer to pay part of the premiums as part of the package (DOL guide to COBRA). If they do, find out how long the help lasts. When a COBRA subsidy ends, it doesn't open a new window to join a Marketplace plan, so plan for that date (DOL FAQ).
6. What it limits after you leave
Look for non-compete, non-solicit, confidentiality and non-disparagement clauses, and read exactly how broad they are. A non-compete can decide which jobs you're allowed to take next.
- Non-competes. The Federal Trade Commission's national ban never took effect and is no longer being pursued (FTC). Whether a non-compete can be enforced depends on your state.
- Confidentiality and non-disparagement. In 2023 the National Labor Relations Board ruled that an employer can't offer most non-supervisory employees a severance agreement with broad clauses like these (NLRB). That rule is under challenge. As of this writing the Board still treats it as precedent, but its own General Counsel has asked it to overturn it. Don't count on it protecting you. Have a lawyer read these clauses.
7. The rest of the package, and unemployment
- Retirement account. Money you put into a 401(k) is always yours. An employer match follows the plan's vesting schedule, and anything not yet vested can be lost. If you're close to a vesting date, find out how your last day affects it (IRS).
- Stock, bonus, reference. These come from your plan documents and contract, so check each one. Ask for a neutral reference or an agreed statement about your departure if that matters to you.
- Unemployment benefits. Many states treat severance as income that reduces or delays your benefits, and others don't (DOL comparison of state laws). File anyway and report the payments the way your state asks. Be wary of any clause where you promise not to file. New York's attorney general has said waivers of unemployment rights are void, and other states differ.
Can you negotiate?
Sometimes. The EEOC notes that terms in group layoff programs are typically not negotiable, while senior executives often negotiate. Even so, it costs nothing to ask by email whether anything is flexible. The usual requests are more time, a longer COBRA subsidy, a reference, or a say in how your departure is announced. The worst answer is no.
If you'd rather not decide alone, an employment lawyer can read an agreement in a short consultation, and many offer a first one at a low price or free. And if you haven't yet filed for benefits, our step-by-step guide walks through it.
Sources
- U.S. Department of Labor: Severance pay
- EEOC: Understanding waivers of discrimination claims in employee severance agreements
- 29 CFR 1625.22: Waivers of rights and claims under the ADEA
- IRS Publication 15: Employer's tax guide
- IRS: What if I lose my job?
- U.S. Department of Labor: A Worker's Guide to Health Benefits Under COBRA
- U.S. Department of Labor: COBRA FAQs for workers
- Federal Trade Commission: Non-compete rule
- NLRB: Board rules that employers may not offer severance agreements requiring broad confidentiality and non-disparagement terms
- IRS: Retirement topics, vesting
- U.S. Department of Labor: Vacation leave
- U.S. Department of Labor: Comparison of State Unemployment Insurance Laws, nonmonetary eligibility